Get a playlist! Standalone player Get Ringtones

Friday, October 23, 2009

Descartes II

Descartes has rather odd ideas concerning the senses and the mind. Basically, he says that in our search for absolute, unquestionable truth, we must realize that the senses deceive us. He uses this as one of many examples of the deception of the senses.

"[F]or example, I find in my mind two wholly diverse ideas
of the
sun; the one, by which it appears to me extremely
small draws its
origin from the senses[...]; the other,
by which it seems to be many
times larger than the whole
earth, is taken up on astronomical
grounds, that is,
elicited from certain notions born with me, or is
framed
by myself in some other manner. These two ideas cannot

certainly both resemble the same sun; and reason teaches
me that
the one which seems to have immediately emanated
from it [the
former]is the most unlike."

Therefore, he reasons, all that is left to rely on is the mind.
One of the problems with this idea is that the senses have no will of their own. They are faculties of the body which collect data about the world around us and about ourselves. They are not capable of deceiving. What deceives us is the part of our mind that deciphers the information collected from our senses.
Also, one must keep in mind that the senses aren't the only faculties we have for learning and figuring things out. They can only go so far, but reason can go farther. For example, the senses teach us tat the sun gives light and heat. Reason goes on to teach us that it is immobile, extremely large, etc.
The fact that what we learn from the senses is rarely the entire truth because the senses are limited and because we do not always understand the data they collect correctly is no reason for disregarding them.

(Thank you, Joe, for your input in this problem.)

1 comment:

  1. I agree with you about the senses that they are not deceiving but rather not complete in themselves. They must be understood with the help of reason. This is one of the things that makes us different from animals because they have no reason, everything is based on sensual experience.

    ReplyDelete

Share what you are thinking and ask lots of questions...